The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is the main judicial branch of the United Nations (UN). It is responsible for settling disputes between states through its rulings. The dispute between Malaysia and Indonesia over the sovereignty of the Ligitan and Sipadan islands was brought to the ICJ in 2002. The court’s decision on this matter was finally handed down in 2002.
International Court Decision on Ligitan and Sipadan Islands
The ICJ found that both Malaysia and Indonesia had valid claims to the islands. However, the court ruled that the islands should be given to Malaysia. It reasoned that Malaysia had demonstrated a stronger case for sovereignty over the islands, having shown that it had exercised effective control over the islands since the 1930s. The court also noted that the islands were closer to the Malaysian mainland than to the Indonesian mainland, and that the inhabitants of the islands had a closer cultural and economic connection to Malaysia than to Indonesia.
The court also noted that there was evidence that Indonesia had not exercised effective control over the islands, citing the lack of Indonesian presence on the islands and the lack of Indonesian laws or regulations in the area. The court also noted that the islands were not included in the list of territories that Indonesia had claimed in its submission to the UN in 1945.
The court’s ruling was final and binding on both parties.
Outcome of the Dispute between Malaysia and Indonesia
The ICJ’s decision on the Ligitan and Sipadan islands dispute was a victory for Malaysia. The court’s decision gave Malaysia sovereignty over the islands and the surrounding waters. This gave Malaysia the right to exploit the natural resources in the area, such as oil and gas. It also gave Malaysia exclusive rights to the surrounding waters for fishing and other activities.
The ruling was also a victory for Indonesia in that it recognized the country’s valid claim to the islands. However, the court’s decision to give the islands to Malaysia was a setback for Indonesia, as it was unable to gain control of the islands and their resources.
The dispute between Malaysia and Indonesia over the sovereignty of the Ligitan and Sipadan islands was a long and heated one. In 2002, the International Court of Justice finally handed down its decision on the matter, ruling that the islands should be given to Malaysia. This decision was a victory for Malaysia, as it gave the country sovereignty over the islands and their resources. It was also a victory for Indonesia in that it recognized the country’s valid claim to the islands.